Orange Key Realty

Since opening its doors in 2007, Orange Key Realty has grown into one of New Jersey’s most respected and reliable real estate agencies. Based in Monmouth Junction, the firm now stands proudly at approximately 45 skilled and experienced agents. Despite operating independently, these agents work together as a close-knit family, always stepping up for one another to ensure clients receive top-tier service. But where did this successful agency begin? Let’s rewind to where it all began.

Michael Matthews, co-owner and broker at Orange Key Realty, was destined for a people-centric career from a young age. Naturally charismatic and an excellent communicator, Michael had an innate ability to connect with others and understand their needs. Although his early career path took a few turns, once he discovered real estate, it was clear he had found his calling. Michael quickly rose to become one of New Jersey’s top-producing agents, gaining recognition across the state. While attending industry events and awards ceremonies, he crossed paths with another standout agent, Ofir Hillel. The two shared a strong work ethic and a passion for customer service. Their chemistry was undeniable, and in 2007, they joined forces to create Orange Key Realty— a place where communication, trust, and impeccable service are always at the forefront.

Over the years, Michael and Ofir have racked up numerous accolades that speak to their commitment and success in the industry. Both have earned the prestigious NJAR Platinum Level Award every year from 2013 through 2024, and have also been recognized among the Top 10 Best Real Estate Agents by the American Institute of Real Estate between the years of 2016 and 2024. Additionally, Michael was granted the CJMLS Presidents Award from 2020 to 2022, a distinction given to those with the highest number of listings sold in Middlesex County. Yet, Michael and Ofir’s greatest achievements lie not in awards, but in the countless glowing reviews from satisfied clients who have experienced the Orange Key difference.

At Orange Key Realty, the client always comes first. Every agent on the team understands that each client’s situation is unique, so personalized marketing strategies and tailored service are a standard part of their approach. The Orange Key agents provide consistent updates throughout the buying or selling process, ensuring that no question goes unanswered. Plus, known for their outstanding negotiating skills, the team fights tirelessly on behalf of their clients, determined to secure the best possible outcome in every transaction.

Orange Key Realty’s success is built on more than just great communication and professionalism— it’s rooted in constant growth. Each agent undergoes continuous training to stay ahead of the rapidly evolving world of real estate. With one of the most qualified and compassionate teams in the industry, Orange Key ensures that clients are in expert hands. So, if you’re looking to buy or sell property in New Jersey, know that Orange Key Realty offers not only unbeatable service, but also the key to the property of your dreams.